[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ TimeZone Public Forum ] [ FAQ ]
Posted by Mike Bilow on September 13, 2000 at
04:47:15:
In Reply to: OK, interesting Mike ... posted by Conrad C. Nobili
on September 13, 2000 at 03:41:09:
Posted from Host: prov05-pm3.intap.net (208.131.219.197)
Obviously, if you hit the water with enough force to kill you, you don't care about your watch. My point, however, is that it is possible to enter water with enormous forces. The force necessary to compromise a seal on a watch is probably a great deal smaller, by orders of magnitude, than it would take to kill a person.
When you enter the water aggressively, say in a hands-first dive, the water must exert force on your in order to decelerate you fairly rapidly. This force is, by definition, distributed over some area as pressure. In an extreme case, of course, this could crush the watch and kill the diver, but it takes nowhere near that amount of force to compromise the seals. The area of impact is therefore critical: if you distribute the force over a wider area, then the pressure at any point is much less.
-- Mike
: Some very good points here. I suppose a small bit of elastomer would probably provide
hysteresis for even a simple depth guage such as that in a watch, so you could be correct
about watch depth guages working like other diving depth guages. But we don't really know
for sure. Ludwig did say that his seemed to be quite responsive with some sort of test
rig, so that may counter your argument for his particular watch.
: You don't seriously think that anyone is concerned about his watch after a fatal impact with the water surface do you? ;-) Basically, I'm pretty sure that if you survive an impact, your watch will probably only barely have noticed it -- remember we're trying to reach levels of forces that threaten the watch yet don't kill the human. The most extreme way to enter the water would seem to be in a hands first dive, with maximum velocity water rushing by and around the crown/pushers. But Ed (I think) showed the math for the terminal velocity of a human in freefall and the uninteresting results on a watch. Does anyone know a Venezuelan cliff diver? Perhaps we could get some real world results. Anyway, it seems highly unlikely to me that swishing water around the crown/pushers at these pressures and velocities is a big deal.
: And water is very different than a wall. It's only sort of like a wall to a belly flopping human because a human in that conformation is also sort of like a wall, and of some appreciable extent. A watch is a much smaller, much less flat thing. The biological effects on a big flat soft human smacking the water are very different from the mechanical effects on a small lumpy hard watch in the same situation.
: Oh, and BTW, I don't need crumple zones in my '76 Lincoln Continental four door sedan -- because all you folks have them in your newer cars! ;-) I just better not run into another beast like mine. ;-(
: --cn
: Conrad C. Nobili Conrad_Nobili@Harvard.EDU Harvard University NDTL/NOC
Copyright © 1998, Power Reserve Inc., All Rights Reserved